2024.07.12 · AI-translated
Some thoughts on AI image generation and the social responsibility of artists
I don’t remember learning about “defensive democracy” in social studies class as a kid, even though it’s an important idea. At least I have no memory of ever voting on “whether to abolish voting.” I wonder if it’s part of compulsory education now.
It suddenly came to mind because of a new AI model that can “generate a video of the painting process from a single image”: Paints-Undo. And it can produce a convincing-looking process for any style at all.
Illustrators were already furious that AI developers trained drawing models on their images and stole their styles. Now this makes it even harder for them to prove “I drew this myself” with process recordings. Some people think the output is only good enough to fool amateurs and does nothing for actual creative work, so there’s been similar criticism in both the Taiwanese and Japanese communities: “an invention full of malice,” “I can’t think of any use for it other than deceiving people.” Some people even put curses on the developer.
Setting aside the developer’s intentions, and whether the output will someday get good enough to pass their standards, it reminded me of a dilemma similar to the one democracy has: creators have creative freedom, but the creative environment itself can be threatened by a work. (In this case, opening up a new field came at the cost of another group of creators. Maybe some illustrators benefit too, but for now the damage looks bigger.)
Video taken from the Paints-Undo demo.
When people talk about the social responsibility of artists, the discussion usually centers on the function of art, the freedom and purity of creation, or the position that creation is fundamentally personal. But after seeing how illustrators reacted this time, “not destroying the existing creative environment” might become one of the things I consider from now on.
Of course, there’s no way I’d ever invent something that overturns an entire layer of technology. The more likely situation is something like this: when a foreign institution invites me to exhibit, I always want to sneak in some political message. But with this way of thinking, I might tone the political message down so I don’t get the exhibition organizers in trouble or drag other creators in the same circle into it. I’m not sure whether that’s too much self-censorship, though. And whether something counts as destruction is hard to judge unless you look over a long enough time span.
Back to AI. I’m not an AI developer, but as someone who writes code, I really understand the urge to use code to get infinitely close to reality, so I admire the technology itself. (Whether it was right to release it to the public at this stage is harder for me to say.)
I still want to stay neutral about technology. I wonder if dynamite went through something similar when it was first invented. Some people thought it could be used for demolition someday, and others used it for robbery. The problem always lies with the user. But even if everyone knows the proper use, if tearing down a bridge by hand doesn’t offer some irreplaceable value, the people who can only take bridges apart with manual labor will still have to learn a new method or change jobs.
In the long run, I think AI’s effect on creative work will still be a good one. Leaving aside all its features, I think the annoying stuff it churns out could actually help raise the quality of human creative work. A flood of images and music that look impressive at first glance wears people out, and once they’re worn out, my guess is that works with nothing but surface features will get ignored more and more, while things beyond technique will be valued more and more: the intent behind the work, its conceptual side, the story, and emotional connections that only work because they’re real. (Though sooner or later AI will probably understand life better than we do.)
For people who only want to compete on style, this change might be pretty brutal. You finally land on a style nobody’s seen before, and then you have to worry about it getting stolen right away. Sigh. Actively talking with AI developers about what we actually need might be one direction worth working on. I hope developers and illustrators don’t end up as enemies.